• About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Submit Story Ideas
Subscribe
The Coastal
  • Development
    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Publix to anchor Crossings at Wildlight

    The Phoenix Bar & Bowling, Jacksonville, FL

    4 Older Neighborhoods in Jax with Big Potential

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Beach Bowl making a comeback

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Rooms To Go coming to Town Center area

    Dochi, Jacksonville, FL

    Japanese Donut Pop-Up Shop Dochi Coming to Town Center

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Concert venue, rooftop bar proposed downtown

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Margaritaville Hotel opens in Jax Beach

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Berkman Plaza II (finally) coming down for redevelopment

    New Renderings Show Bright Future for Laura Street Trio

    New Renderings Show Bright Future for Laura Street Trio

  • History
    • All
    • Jax Evolved
    The Phoenix Bar & Bowling, Jacksonville, FL

    4 Older Neighborhoods in Jax with Big Potential

    Stanton High School Jacksonville FL

    Remembering the Old Stanton Normal School

    Snyder Memorial Methodist Episcopal Church, Jacksonville, FL

    Story of a Building: Snyder Memorial Methodist Episcopal Church

    Levy's department store, Jacksonville, FL

    Levy’s Department Store Once Dressed Jacksonville’s Elite

    Skinners' Dairy milk retail huts, Jacksonville, FL

    Remembering Hardwick & Lee’s Distinctive Skinners’ Dairy Huts

    VyStar Tower, Jacksonville, FL

    Story of a Building: VyStar Tower

    Joseph E. Lee Jacksonville's first black attorney

    Joseph E. Lee Was Jacksonville’s First Black Lawyer – and He Didn’t Stop There

    Jacksonville Public Library

    Story of a Building: Jacksonville Main Library

    Riverplace Tower, Jacksonville FL

    Story of a Building: Riverplace Tower

  • Culture
    • All
    • Art
    • Hidden Gems
    • Local Quirks
    • Music
    • Shopping
    “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

    Sugar Ray, Quad City DJ’s Highlight Jax River Jams Lineup

    Art Notes - Jacksonville, FL

    ART NOTES: Jazz Discovery Series 2021 Kicks off Friday Night

    “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

    “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

    Joseph E. Lee Jacksonville's first black attorney

    Joseph E. Lee Was Jacksonville’s First Black Lawyer – and He Didn’t Stop There

    Confederate monument removed in Jacksonville, FL

    5 Biggest Local Stories of 2020

    Jacksonville Zoo

    A Brief History of the Jacksonville Zoo and Gardens

    MOSH Genesis rendering

    MOSH Releases Conceptual Renderings for Proposed Northbank Museum

    LaRose Women's Footwear, Jacksonville, FL

    Remembering LaRose, Jacksonville’s Famous Women’s Shoe Store

    The Homestead Restaurant, Jacksonville Beach, FL

    Long Before Taco Lu, There Was The Homestead Restaurant

  • Community
    Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

    Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

    Cowford Chophouse Partners with JAMS for 2021 MOO-VE IT 5K

    Cowford Chophouse Partners with JAMS for 2021 MOO-VE IT 5K

    Taverna Meals for Medical Workers Jacksonville Baptist Health

    Taverna Gives Back to First Responders with “Meals for Medical Workers”

    Local Companies Anact, SurfearNEGRA Join Forces to Address Aquatic Inequality

    Local Companies Anact, SurfearNEGRA Join Forces to Address Aquatic Inequality

    The Pitman Sisters, TikTok video stars from Jacksonville, FL

    How “The Pitman Sisters” Became TikTok Famous During COVID-19

    Local Women in Cannabis, Jacksonville, FL

    Breaking the “Grass Ceiling”: Local Women in Cannabis

    Urban Mining Jacksonville FL

    How Urban Mining Utilizes Donations to Provide Computers for Local Kids

    Cowford Chophouse Teams Up with Jacksonville Arts & Music School for 4th Annual MOO-VE IT 5K

    Cowford Chophouse Raises Over $18,000 for Jacksonville Arts & Music School

    COVID-19 Testing homeless population in Jacksonville, FL

    Entire Jacksonville Homeless Shelter Population Tests Negative for COVID-19

  • Food + Drink
    • All
    • Beer
    • Reviews
    Dochi, Jacksonville, FL

    Japanese Donut Pop-Up Shop Dochi Coming to Town Center

    Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

    Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

    Taverna Meals for Medical Workers Jacksonville Baptist Health

    Taverna Gives Back to First Responders with “Meals for Medical Workers”

    The Homestead Restaurant, Jacksonville Beach, FL

    Long Before Taco Lu, There Was The Homestead Restaurant

    Norikase Jacksonville

    BENTO Group to Debut Norikase Concept in Jacksonville

    Chef Tom Gray Introduces Line of Grocery Store Culinary Products

    Chef Tom Gray Introduces Line of Grocery Store Culinary Products

    Palace Saloon, Fernandina Beach, FL

    Florida’s Oldest Bar, the Palace Saloon, Can Be Found on Amelia Island

    Farms in Jacksonville, FL

    5 Great Local Farms in Jacksonville

    The Volstead, Jacksonville, FL

    HIDDEN GEMS: The Volstead, Downtown Jacksonville’s Speakeasy

  • More
    • Hidden Gems
    • Local Quirks
    • Lists
    • Sports
    • 904VIEWS
    • Seven Bridges
    • Music
No Result
View All Result
The Coastal
  • Development
    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Publix to anchor Crossings at Wildlight

    The Phoenix Bar & Bowling, Jacksonville, FL

    4 Older Neighborhoods in Jax with Big Potential

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Beach Bowl making a comeback

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Rooms To Go coming to Town Center area

    Dochi, Jacksonville, FL

    Japanese Donut Pop-Up Shop Dochi Coming to Town Center

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Concert venue, rooftop bar proposed downtown

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Margaritaville Hotel opens in Jax Beach

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Berkman Plaza II (finally) coming down for redevelopment

    New Renderings Show Bright Future for Laura Street Trio

    New Renderings Show Bright Future for Laura Street Trio

  • History
    • All
    • Jax Evolved
    The Phoenix Bar & Bowling, Jacksonville, FL

    4 Older Neighborhoods in Jax with Big Potential

    Stanton High School Jacksonville FL

    Remembering the Old Stanton Normal School

    Snyder Memorial Methodist Episcopal Church, Jacksonville, FL

    Story of a Building: Snyder Memorial Methodist Episcopal Church

    Levy's department store, Jacksonville, FL

    Levy’s Department Store Once Dressed Jacksonville’s Elite

    Skinners' Dairy milk retail huts, Jacksonville, FL

    Remembering Hardwick & Lee’s Distinctive Skinners’ Dairy Huts

    VyStar Tower, Jacksonville, FL

    Story of a Building: VyStar Tower

    Joseph E. Lee Jacksonville's first black attorney

    Joseph E. Lee Was Jacksonville’s First Black Lawyer – and He Didn’t Stop There

    Jacksonville Public Library

    Story of a Building: Jacksonville Main Library

    Riverplace Tower, Jacksonville FL

    Story of a Building: Riverplace Tower

  • Culture
    • All
    • Art
    • Hidden Gems
    • Local Quirks
    • Music
    • Shopping
    “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

    Sugar Ray, Quad City DJ’s Highlight Jax River Jams Lineup

    Art Notes - Jacksonville, FL

    ART NOTES: Jazz Discovery Series 2021 Kicks off Friday Night

    “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

    “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

    Joseph E. Lee Jacksonville's first black attorney

    Joseph E. Lee Was Jacksonville’s First Black Lawyer – and He Didn’t Stop There

    Confederate monument removed in Jacksonville, FL

    5 Biggest Local Stories of 2020

    Jacksonville Zoo

    A Brief History of the Jacksonville Zoo and Gardens

    MOSH Genesis rendering

    MOSH Releases Conceptual Renderings for Proposed Northbank Museum

    LaRose Women's Footwear, Jacksonville, FL

    Remembering LaRose, Jacksonville’s Famous Women’s Shoe Store

    The Homestead Restaurant, Jacksonville Beach, FL

    Long Before Taco Lu, There Was The Homestead Restaurant

  • Community
    Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

    Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

    Cowford Chophouse Partners with JAMS for 2021 MOO-VE IT 5K

    Cowford Chophouse Partners with JAMS for 2021 MOO-VE IT 5K

    Taverna Meals for Medical Workers Jacksonville Baptist Health

    Taverna Gives Back to First Responders with “Meals for Medical Workers”

    Local Companies Anact, SurfearNEGRA Join Forces to Address Aquatic Inequality

    Local Companies Anact, SurfearNEGRA Join Forces to Address Aquatic Inequality

    The Pitman Sisters, TikTok video stars from Jacksonville, FL

    How “The Pitman Sisters” Became TikTok Famous During COVID-19

    Local Women in Cannabis, Jacksonville, FL

    Breaking the “Grass Ceiling”: Local Women in Cannabis

    Urban Mining Jacksonville FL

    How Urban Mining Utilizes Donations to Provide Computers for Local Kids

    Cowford Chophouse Teams Up with Jacksonville Arts & Music School for 4th Annual MOO-VE IT 5K

    Cowford Chophouse Raises Over $18,000 for Jacksonville Arts & Music School

    COVID-19 Testing homeless population in Jacksonville, FL

    Entire Jacksonville Homeless Shelter Population Tests Negative for COVID-19

  • Food + Drink
    • All
    • Beer
    • Reviews
    Dochi, Jacksonville, FL

    Japanese Donut Pop-Up Shop Dochi Coming to Town Center

    Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

    Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

    Taverna Meals for Medical Workers Jacksonville Baptist Health

    Taverna Gives Back to First Responders with “Meals for Medical Workers”

    The Homestead Restaurant, Jacksonville Beach, FL

    Long Before Taco Lu, There Was The Homestead Restaurant

    Norikase Jacksonville

    BENTO Group to Debut Norikase Concept in Jacksonville

    Chef Tom Gray Introduces Line of Grocery Store Culinary Products

    Chef Tom Gray Introduces Line of Grocery Store Culinary Products

    Palace Saloon, Fernandina Beach, FL

    Florida’s Oldest Bar, the Palace Saloon, Can Be Found on Amelia Island

    Farms in Jacksonville, FL

    5 Great Local Farms in Jacksonville

    The Volstead, Jacksonville, FL

    HIDDEN GEMS: The Volstead, Downtown Jacksonville’s Speakeasy

  • More
    • Hidden Gems
    • Local Quirks
    • Lists
    • Sports
    • 904VIEWS
    • Seven Bridges
    • Music
No Result
View All Result
The Coastal
No Result
View All Result

Downtown Jacksonville Will Be Fine Without Lot J

by The Coastal
January 13, 2021
in Commentary, Development
Lot J Live District rendering Jacksonville FL

Rendering via COJ

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Last night, after hours of discussion and months of controversy, Jacksonville’s city council voted by the narrowest of margins to reject the proposed Lot J development from the Jaguars and The Cordish Companies. And while some residents were happy to see the council take their concerns seriously, others were decidedly less optimistic – including Mayor Lenny Curry himself.

“This sends a clear and negative e [sic] message to economic development in our downtown and city,” Curry tweeted last night immediately following the council vote. Others, including various Jaguars morning radio personalities, have offered similar sentiments insisting that, without Lot J going forward, downtown Jacksonville is permanently destined to fail.

That simply isn’t true, and to explain why, perhaps it would be appropriate to think of downtown development in football terms.

Lot J represented a clear attempt at a “Hail Mary” play – trying to go for a quick touchdown to get points on the board as soon as possible. It’s a play call that is utilized almost exclusively when time is running out, usually right before the end of the game.

Here’s the problem: downtown Jacksonville hasn’t gotten to the end of the game yet. After being neglected and even actively destroyed by local politicians for decades, the city has only recently started attempting in earnest to get it back on track in the past few years. And there’s no firm deadline being sought – aside from reaching 10,000 residents within the next few years, which Lot J by itself obviously wouldn’t have accomplished.

At best, in this metaphor, downtown Jax is somewhere in the middle of the second quarter. There’s no practical need to aim solely for the end-zone right now, after years of steady, incremental progress that includes the completion of The Barnett’s revitalization, surpassing 6,000 residents downtown for the first time in decades, and reducing the downtown office vacancy rate to under 15%.

You MightAlso Like

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Publix to anchor Crossings at Wildlight

The Phoenix Bar & Bowling, Jacksonville, FL

4 Older Neighborhoods in Jax with Big Potential

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Beach Bowl making a comeback

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Rooms To Go coming to Town Center area

Instead, the city should be looking to complete more relatively short pass plays, so to speak. Projects like the proposed adaptive reuse of the historic Ambassador Hotel and Independent Life buildings, the continued development of affordable housing complexes, and the proposed mixed-use development at the Ford on Bay may not be quite as exciting, nor do they come with pie-in-the-sky renderings that generate instant buzz. But they move the “team” – downtown Jax, in this instance – further toward the final goal, which is bringing people downtown and getting them to stay there.

Lot J, on the other hand, was planned for the outskirts of downtown, separated from the core of downtown by a stretch that includes an industrial site, the county jail, an abandoned metal shell of a building, and an empty lot, and wasn’t substantially different from similar Live! District developments by Cordish in other markets. It was a cookie-cutter deal, negotiated incompetently by the Mayor’s office, with the goal of making downtown Jax active again without having to do any of the hard work involved in creating smaller, more incremental progress.

Hail Mary plays are exciting and electrifying when they work, but it’s the “when they work” part that’s the key problem. In the NFL, Hail Mary plays work less than 10% of the time. In urban development, targeting the glitzy-but-impractical proposal and throwing money at it indiscriminately tends to work out in a similar way.

That’s not to say the big plays can’t happen. The Laura Street Trio project, when completed, would certainly qualify as one. What’s important is that these big plays don’t begin to form the basis for the city’s downtown revitalization strategy. The goals remain the same: get to 10,000 residents, increase density, create destinations, and activate the riverfront. Lot J may have inched us closer to one or two of those goals, but it wouldn’t have gotten us in the end-zone by itself.

It may be in the Jags’ best interest for the city to pull off a Hail Mary, especially one right next to TIAA Bank Field, but it’s in the city’s best interest to stay the course on revitalizing the downtown area.

ShareTweetSendShareShare
Previous Post

Story of a Building: Jacksonville Main Library

Next Post

Building Up Jax: JWB Real Estate Capital eyes two adaptive reuse projects downtown

The Coastal

The Coastal is a local magazine in Jacksonville, FL, founded in 2015 to bring you stories about the past, present, and future of the First Coast.

Related Posts

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Publix to anchor Crossings at Wildlight

The Phoenix Bar & Bowling, Jacksonville, FL

4 Older Neighborhoods in Jax with Big Potential

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Beach Bowl making a comeback

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Rooms To Go coming to Town Center area

Dochi, Jacksonville, FL

Japanese Donut Pop-Up Shop Dochi Coming to Town Center

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Concert venue, rooftop bar proposed downtown

Next Post
Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: JWB Real Estate Capital eyes two adaptive reuse projects downtown

Joseph E. Lee Jacksonville's first black attorney

Joseph E. Lee Was Jacksonville’s First Black Lawyer – and He Didn’t Stop There

New Renderings Show Bright Future for Laura Street Trio

New Renderings Show Bright Future for Laura Street Trio

Comments 2

  1. Dr. Doright. says:
    2 months ago

    That is a laughable analogy and about as naive as I’ve seen in awhile, even from Coastal. This issue isn’t about a game. And there is no touchdown end point. For the realist, life isn’t a metaphor, its about actions and consequences. The commission’s action will result in stunted growth and protracted under development for downtown. And it may very well lead to the loss of the major draw for that area.

    Reply
    • The Coastal says:
      2 months ago

      It’s city council, not a commission, but sounds like you’ve got everything figured out there chief.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

LATEST POSTS

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday
Development

Building Up Jax: Publix to anchor Crossings at Wildlight

Publix to anchor Crossings at Wildlight Wildlight has officially landed its biggest retail tenant yet: Publix. The Nassau County master-planned...

Read more
The Phoenix Bar & Bowling, Jacksonville, FL

4 Older Neighborhoods in Jax with Big Potential

“Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

Sugar Ray, Quad City DJ’s Highlight Jax River Jams Lineup

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Beach Bowl making a comeback

Stanton High School Jacksonville FL

Remembering the Old Stanton Normal School

The Coastal

© 2015-2020 Cowford Media / The Coastal Jacksonville LLC. All rights reserved.

Browse by Section

  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Submit Story Ideas

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Development
  • Culture
  • History
    • Jax Evolved
  • In the Community
  • Food + Drink
  • Sports
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • Submit Your Story
    • Advertise

© 2015-2020 Cowford Media / The Coastal Jacksonville LLC. All rights reserved.