The Coastal
  • Development
    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: MOSH releases new Northbank renderings

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Whataburger adding third new Jax location

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Whataburger now open in St. Johns, coming soon in Middleburg

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: East San Marco tenants revealed

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Homespun Kitchen expanding to Riverside

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Vagabond Coffee joining VyStar Tower; Dreamette to Springfield

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Great Greek nears St. Johns opening; Hwy 55 Burgers coming to Westside

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Purple Roots now open at Tinseltown

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Fire museum on the move; Dreamette to San Marco

  • History
    • All
    • Jax Evolved
    Florida Times-Union building

    Story of a Building: The Florida Times-Union Building

    Edgewood Bakery

    Remembering Edgewood Bakery: Once a Murray Hill Staple, Now an Empty Building

    jacksonville university

    A Brief History of Jacksonville University

    history of Ed wAters College

    A Brief History of Edward Waters College

    Worman's bAKERY AND DELI

    Remembering Worman’s Bakery and Deli

    Before Normandy Mall, There Was the Loew’s Normandy Drive-In Theatre

    Before Normandy Mall, There Was the Loew’s Normandy Drive-In Theatre

    Green Turtle Restaurant in Jacksonville, fl

    Remembering Joe Adeeb’s Green Turtle Restaurant

    San Marco Theater, San Marco, Jacksonville, FL

    Story of a Building: San Marco Theatre

    Sun-Ray Cinema building Five Points Jacksonville FL

    Story of a Building: Sun-Ray Cinema Building

  • Jax Evolved
    VyStar at 100 West Bay Street, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: VyStar Reinvigorates the Former Life of the South Building

    JAX EVOLVED: San Marco Preservation Society Now Occupies South Jacksonville City Hall

    JAX EVOLVED: San Marco Preservation Society Now Occupies South Jacksonville City Hall

    Old St. Luke's Hospital jacksonville fl

    JAX EVOLVED: Old St. Luke’s Hospital Building Now Houses Jacksonville Historical Society

    Paul Davis Restoration, formerly Chevrolet Parts Depot, Springfield, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: Paul Davis Restoration Gives Life to Old Chevrolet Parts Depot

    Old St. Andrew's Church building, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: Old St. Andrew’s Church Building

    Novel Coworking / Groover-Stewart Drug Company Building, 25 N. Market Street, Jacksonville, FL - Image copyright 2020 Google

    JAX EVOLVED: Groover-Stewart Drug Company Building Now Houses Novel Coworking

    Dyal-Upchurch Building, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: Downtown Jacksonville Adaptive Reuse Collection

    The Barnett, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: The Barnett’s Long Journey to Redevelopment

    JAX EVOLVED: Brewster Hospital to North Florida Land Trust, LaVilla, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: From Brewster Hospital to North Florida Land Trust

  • More
    • Culture
      • All
      • Art
      • Hidden Gems
      • Local Quirks
      • Music
      • Shopping
      Local Producer Alex Moye Releases New Album, “All I Need”

      Local Producer Alex Moye Releases New Album, “All I Need”

      Jacksonville Jazz Fest to Return This Fall

      Jacksonville Jazz Fest to Return This Fall

      Green Turtle Restaurant in Jacksonville, fl

      Remembering Joe Adeeb’s Green Turtle Restaurant

      Dockless Mobility Program Brings E-Scooters to Downtown Jacksonville

      Dockless Mobility Program Brings E-Scooters to Downtown Jacksonville

      MURAL SPOTLIGHT: Riverside Park Place by Jason Tetlak

      MURAL SPOTLIGHT: Riverside Park Place by Jason Tetlak

      “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

      Sugar Ray, Quad City DJ’s Highlight Jax River Jams Lineup

      Art Notes - Jacksonville, FL

      ART NOTES: Jazz Discovery Series 2021 Kicks off Friday Night

      “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

      “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

      Joseph E. Lee Jacksonville's first black attorney

      Joseph E. Lee Was Jacksonville’s First Black Lawyer – and He Didn’t Stop There

    • Community
      Prati Italia Jacksonville FL

      How the Prati Italia Team Survived the Pandemic

      Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

      Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

      Cowford Chophouse Partners with JAMS for 2021 MOO-VE IT 5K

      Cowford Chophouse Partners with JAMS for 2021 MOO-VE IT 5K

      Taverna Meals for Medical Workers Jacksonville Baptist Health

      Taverna Gives Back to First Responders with “Meals for Medical Workers”

      Local Companies Anact, SurfearNEGRA Join Forces to Address Aquatic Inequality

      Local Companies Anact, SurfearNEGRA Join Forces to Address Aquatic Inequality

      The Pitman Sisters, TikTok video stars from Jacksonville, FL

      How “The Pitman Sisters” Became TikTok Famous During COVID-19

      Local Women in Cannabis, Jacksonville, FL

      Breaking the “Grass Ceiling”: Local Women in Cannabis

      Urban Mining Jacksonville FL

      How Urban Mining Utilizes Donations to Provide Computers for Local Kids

      Cowford Chophouse Teams Up with Jacksonville Arts & Music School for 4th Annual MOO-VE IT 5K

      Cowford Chophouse Raises Over $18,000 for Jacksonville Arts & Music School

    • Food + Drink
      • All
      • Beer
      • Reviews
      Southern Italian Deli Market Jacksonville FL

      Cugino’s Sausage Launches The Southern Italian Deli & Market

      Prati Italia Jacksonville FL

      How the Prati Italia Team Survived the Pandemic

      Crazy Beans Coffee Makes Debut Inside JRTC at LaVilla

      Crazy Beans Coffee Makes Debut Inside JRTC at LaVilla

      Green Turtle Restaurant in Jacksonville, fl

      Remembering Joe Adeeb’s Green Turtle Restaurant

      Dochi, Jacksonville, FL

      Japanese Donut Pop-Up Shop Dochi Coming to Town Center

      Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

      Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

      Taverna Meals for Medical Workers Jacksonville Baptist Health

      Taverna Gives Back to First Responders with “Meals for Medical Workers”

      The Homestead Restaurant, Jacksonville Beach, FL

      Long Before Taco Lu, There Was The Homestead Restaurant

      Norikase Jacksonville

      BENTO Group to Debut Norikase Concept in Jacksonville

    • Hidden Gems
    • Local Quirks
    • Lists
    • Sports
    • 904VIEWS
    • Seven Bridges
    • Music
No Result
View All Result
Subscribe
The Coastal
  • Development
    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: MOSH releases new Northbank renderings

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Whataburger adding third new Jax location

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Whataburger now open in St. Johns, coming soon in Middleburg

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: East San Marco tenants revealed

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Homespun Kitchen expanding to Riverside

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Vagabond Coffee joining VyStar Tower; Dreamette to Springfield

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Great Greek nears St. Johns opening; Hwy 55 Burgers coming to Westside

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Purple Roots now open at Tinseltown

    Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

    Building Up Jax: Fire museum on the move; Dreamette to San Marco

  • History
    • All
    • Jax Evolved
    Florida Times-Union building

    Story of a Building: The Florida Times-Union Building

    Edgewood Bakery

    Remembering Edgewood Bakery: Once a Murray Hill Staple, Now an Empty Building

    jacksonville university

    A Brief History of Jacksonville University

    history of Ed wAters College

    A Brief History of Edward Waters College

    Worman's bAKERY AND DELI

    Remembering Worman’s Bakery and Deli

    Before Normandy Mall, There Was the Loew’s Normandy Drive-In Theatre

    Before Normandy Mall, There Was the Loew’s Normandy Drive-In Theatre

    Green Turtle Restaurant in Jacksonville, fl

    Remembering Joe Adeeb’s Green Turtle Restaurant

    San Marco Theater, San Marco, Jacksonville, FL

    Story of a Building: San Marco Theatre

    Sun-Ray Cinema building Five Points Jacksonville FL

    Story of a Building: Sun-Ray Cinema Building

  • Jax Evolved
    VyStar at 100 West Bay Street, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: VyStar Reinvigorates the Former Life of the South Building

    JAX EVOLVED: San Marco Preservation Society Now Occupies South Jacksonville City Hall

    JAX EVOLVED: San Marco Preservation Society Now Occupies South Jacksonville City Hall

    Old St. Luke's Hospital jacksonville fl

    JAX EVOLVED: Old St. Luke’s Hospital Building Now Houses Jacksonville Historical Society

    Paul Davis Restoration, formerly Chevrolet Parts Depot, Springfield, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: Paul Davis Restoration Gives Life to Old Chevrolet Parts Depot

    Old St. Andrew's Church building, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: Old St. Andrew’s Church Building

    Novel Coworking / Groover-Stewart Drug Company Building, 25 N. Market Street, Jacksonville, FL - Image copyright 2020 Google

    JAX EVOLVED: Groover-Stewart Drug Company Building Now Houses Novel Coworking

    Dyal-Upchurch Building, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: Downtown Jacksonville Adaptive Reuse Collection

    The Barnett, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: The Barnett’s Long Journey to Redevelopment

    JAX EVOLVED: Brewster Hospital to North Florida Land Trust, LaVilla, Jacksonville, FL

    JAX EVOLVED: From Brewster Hospital to North Florida Land Trust

  • More
    • Culture
      • All
      • Art
      • Hidden Gems
      • Local Quirks
      • Music
      • Shopping
      Local Producer Alex Moye Releases New Album, “All I Need”

      Local Producer Alex Moye Releases New Album, “All I Need”

      Jacksonville Jazz Fest to Return This Fall

      Jacksonville Jazz Fest to Return This Fall

      Green Turtle Restaurant in Jacksonville, fl

      Remembering Joe Adeeb’s Green Turtle Restaurant

      Dockless Mobility Program Brings E-Scooters to Downtown Jacksonville

      Dockless Mobility Program Brings E-Scooters to Downtown Jacksonville

      MURAL SPOTLIGHT: Riverside Park Place by Jason Tetlak

      MURAL SPOTLIGHT: Riverside Park Place by Jason Tetlak

      “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

      Sugar Ray, Quad City DJ’s Highlight Jax River Jams Lineup

      Art Notes - Jacksonville, FL

      ART NOTES: Jazz Discovery Series 2021 Kicks off Friday Night

      “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

      “Jax River Jams” Concert Series Coming to Riverfront Plaza in April

      Joseph E. Lee Jacksonville's first black attorney

      Joseph E. Lee Was Jacksonville’s First Black Lawyer – and He Didn’t Stop There

    • Community
      Prati Italia Jacksonville FL

      How the Prati Italia Team Survived the Pandemic

      Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

      Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

      Cowford Chophouse Partners with JAMS for 2021 MOO-VE IT 5K

      Cowford Chophouse Partners with JAMS for 2021 MOO-VE IT 5K

      Taverna Meals for Medical Workers Jacksonville Baptist Health

      Taverna Gives Back to First Responders with “Meals for Medical Workers”

      Local Companies Anact, SurfearNEGRA Join Forces to Address Aquatic Inequality

      Local Companies Anact, SurfearNEGRA Join Forces to Address Aquatic Inequality

      The Pitman Sisters, TikTok video stars from Jacksonville, FL

      How “The Pitman Sisters” Became TikTok Famous During COVID-19

      Local Women in Cannabis, Jacksonville, FL

      Breaking the “Grass Ceiling”: Local Women in Cannabis

      Urban Mining Jacksonville FL

      How Urban Mining Utilizes Donations to Provide Computers for Local Kids

      Cowford Chophouse Teams Up with Jacksonville Arts & Music School for 4th Annual MOO-VE IT 5K

      Cowford Chophouse Raises Over $18,000 for Jacksonville Arts & Music School

    • Food + Drink
      • All
      • Beer
      • Reviews
      Southern Italian Deli Market Jacksonville FL

      Cugino’s Sausage Launches The Southern Italian Deli & Market

      Prati Italia Jacksonville FL

      How the Prati Italia Team Survived the Pandemic

      Crazy Beans Coffee Makes Debut Inside JRTC at LaVilla

      Crazy Beans Coffee Makes Debut Inside JRTC at LaVilla

      Green Turtle Restaurant in Jacksonville, fl

      Remembering Joe Adeeb’s Green Turtle Restaurant

      Dochi, Jacksonville, FL

      Japanese Donut Pop-Up Shop Dochi Coming to Town Center

      Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

      Jax-Based SipClean Debuts New Canned, Non-Alcoholic Rosé

      Taverna Meals for Medical Workers Jacksonville Baptist Health

      Taverna Gives Back to First Responders with “Meals for Medical Workers”

      The Homestead Restaurant, Jacksonville Beach, FL

      Long Before Taco Lu, There Was The Homestead Restaurant

      Norikase Jacksonville

      BENTO Group to Debut Norikase Concept in Jacksonville

    • Hidden Gems
    • Local Quirks
    • Lists
    • Sports
    • 904VIEWS
    • Seven Bridges
    • Music
No Result
View All Result
The Coastal
No Result
View All Result

Is It Time to Remove the Confederate Monument from Hemming Park?

by The Coastal
June 1, 2017 - Updated on June 4, 2020
in Culture, Featured, In the Community
Confederate monument in Hemming Park
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

As you’ve probably figured out by now, we’re big fans of the city’s history.

We support the preservation of Jacksonville’s historical structures, and of stories of the city’s history. This includes even the ugly parts – if for no other reason than to try not to make the same mistakes again.

But while all parts of our history should be preserved, are there some things that aren’t worthy of being celebrated?

In recent years, a national debate has been sparked over the presence of monuments depicting Confederate soldiers that have long been placed throughout city squares in many southern states. Several cities across the country have removed their monuments, but not without quite a bit of protest and hateful commentary.

Meanwhile, in downtown Jacksonville’s busiest park, a Confederate memorial statue installed in 1898 still stands. But should it stay there?

The monument, located in the center of Hemming Park, was donated by Civil War veteran Charles Hemming. It was intended to serve as a memorial for soldiers and sailors who fought in the Civil War – on the side of the Confederacy, to be specific. A city council bill aimed at making the statue a historic landmark was withdrawn after community backlash, but there are also no imminent plans to remove it.

You MightAlso Like

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Rogue Dawgs Bark and Brew coming to Flagler Center

Local Producer Alex Moye Releases New Album, “All I Need”

Local Producer Alex Moye Releases New Album, “All I Need”

Prati Italia Jacksonville FL

How the Prati Italia Team Survived the Pandemic

Jacksonville Jazz Fest to Return This Fall

Jacksonville Jazz Fest to Return This Fall

Clearly, there are extremely passionate arguments on both sides of this issue.

Some argue that removing these monuments is the equivalent of erasing history. Others say it’s dishonorable to the soldiers who fought in the war – even if their cause may have been rather dishonorable itself – and that it’s symptomatic of a larger societal problem of “being offended by everything.”

However, those in favor of removal believe that the monuments glamorize those who fought in the name of slavery and white supremacy – causes that were inseparable from, and undeniably intertwined with, the Confederacy. And to have the monument located in the same park that acted as a battleground for racial equality during the ‘60s seems to send highly conflicting messages about the city and its priorities.

There’s really only one thing that the two sides of this argument are capable of agreeing on, and it’s that neither of them has any room for negotiation in their viewpoints.

One potential solution would be to simply relocate the monument. After all, Springfield has a park that is literally named “Confederate Park” which already features memorials to Confederate soldiers. But those in favor of keeping the monument would argue that that park would simply become the next target for eradication, and those against would argue that Confederate Park shouldn’t still exist in 2017 either.

So since no matter what ends up happening, someone’s going to be unhappy, what should the city do?

Here’s what we think.

First of all, the distinction has to made between preserving history and celebrating it. The monument at Hemming Park was added with the goal of celebrating the lives of those who fought for the Confederate cause. If the monument comes down, the memory of the Confederacy is still preserved through several southern museums, history textbooks, and cinema. In other words, there’s no risk of that part of history no longer being preserved just because a monument comes down.

It’s also worth noting that even after the statue’s removal, the park would still be named in honor of a Confederate veteran – so it’s not like the spirit of the Confederacy would disappear from it altogether.

Second, it’s important to note how entangled the Confederacy is with slavery. While some will argue that the Civil War was fought over states’ rights more so than slavery, no one can reasonably argue that the retention of slavery was not one of the South’s primary goals.

As such, a monument to people who fought at least in part for such a reprehensible goal is naturally offensive to the city’s large African-American population. For them, it’s a reminder of the oppression their ancestors once faced – and also a tacit reminder that some of their own neighbors wouldn’t really mind if things were more like they were back then.

So since the monument doesn’t necessarily offer significant value to the community but does present a reminder of, and border on glorifying, uglier times that no one is soon to forget without its presence, it seems like the right thing to do would be to remove the monument from Hemming Park. Another spot could be found for it, either at Confederate Park or in a Civil War museum.

But as far as having it in the middle of Hemming Park? We think it’s time to move past that.

Do you think the monument should be removed? Let us know what you think in the comments section below or on social media!

Tags: downtownhemming parkracism
Share244TweetSendShareShare
Previous Post

IMAGINE JAX: Imagining a Viaduct in San Marco

Next Post

904WKND: Sports, J. Cole at the Landing, and a Doggie Pageant

The Coastal

The Coastal is a local magazine in Jacksonville, FL, founded in 2015 to bring you stories about the past, present, and future of the First Coast.

Related Posts

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Rogue Dawgs Bark and Brew coming to Flagler Center

Local Producer Alex Moye Releases New Album, “All I Need”

Local Producer Alex Moye Releases New Album, “All I Need”

Prati Italia Jacksonville FL

How the Prati Italia Team Survived the Pandemic

Jacksonville Jazz Fest to Return This Fall

Jacksonville Jazz Fest to Return This Fall

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: The Great Greek coming to St. Johns; Concealment Express seeks Southbank HQ

Green Turtle Restaurant in Jacksonville, fl

Remembering Joe Adeeb’s Green Turtle Restaurant

Next Post
#904WKND - Every Friday Morning on coastaljax.com

904WKND: Sports, J. Cole at the Landing, and a Doggie Pageant

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Development and Construction News Every Saturday - The Coastal

Building Up Jax: Vista Brooklyn, Jackson Square, and Barnett Bank

Butler Blvd. signage, Jacksonville, FL

Project Watch: The End of Two Major Road Projects

Comments 5

  1. Eric Christopher Jackson says:
    5 years ago

    This is my second go-round of being a Jacksonville Resident. I grew up in Fort Lauderdale where a Confederate monument has no chance of being built or left standing. So, when I moved here the first time, I was in shock that..not only is there a 62-foot Confederate monument, but it’s smack in the middle of Downtown. On that day, Hemming Park was full of black people. Playing cards, listening to music, buying from food trucks. I asked myself: Am I the only one looking at this? smh. After reading this article I’m asking: Why is anyone ‘worried’ about the memory of those who fought on the wrong side? Honestly. It’s like putting up a monument for someone who committed a terrible crime just so people can remember it. You don’t build monuments for that. Or…at least, you shouldn’t.

    Reply
    • Steve Peterson says:
      3 years ago

      I would refer you to buildings and monuments in Europe where they don’t erase history. Roman (notorious slave owners) architecture for example.

      Reply
      • Daphne Pimenta says:
        3 years ago

        Exactly!

        Reply
  2. Jim says:
    3 years ago

    Read the book 1984 and you might be pleased that the statue is still standing

    Reply
  3. Tim Hoal says:
    2 years ago

    How about removing the Confederate Solder statue band the plaques and sending them to the historical society. The city can come together and find a new person to honor or make it a memorial to service members from our area.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

LATEST POSTS

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday
Development

Building Up Jax: MOSH releases new Northbank renderings

MOSH releases new renderings of Northbank campus MOSH has released new renderings for its future Northbank campus. The renderings, helmed...

Read more
Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Whataburger adding third new Jax location

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Whataburger now open in St. Johns, coming soon in Middleburg

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: East San Marco tenants revealed

Building Up Jax - Jacksonville Construction and Development Updates Each Saturday

Building Up Jax: Homespun Kitchen expanding to Riverside

The Coastal

© 2015-2021 Cowford Media / The Coastal Jacksonville LLC. All rights reserved.

Browse by Section

  • News
  • Culture
  • History
  • In the Community
  • Food + Drink
  • Sports
  • About

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Development
  • Culture
  • History
    • Jax Evolved
  • In the Community
  • Food + Drink
  • Sports
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • Submit Your Story
    • Advertise

© 2015-2021 Cowford Media / The Coastal Jacksonville LLC. All rights reserved.